letters | Mr. brown goes to iowa

Brown kicking tires on presidential bid? A tire kicks back

Scott Brown was in Iowa this month, apparently kicking the tires of a possible presidential bid. It seems he presumes that his experience gives him what it takes to be president.

As best I can tell, Brown’s main credentials consist of six years as a representative to the Massachusetts Legislature, focusing on the needs of his district; six years as a state senator; and then an abbreviated term as a US senator, a position to which he was not reelected in November.

Brown’s credentials are not insubstantial, but they do not show the broad vision that I would like to see in a possible presidential candidate.


Americans freely criticize presidents for their actions and decisions, but, let’s face it, it’s a tough job that requires a wide range of knowledge and skills. I feel that it would be presumptuous of Brown to think that a broad swath of the electorate would consider him to have the requisite knowledge and skills at this point.

Get Arguable in your inbox:
Jeff Jacoby on everything from politics to pet peeves to the passions of the day.
Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

Reports of Brown’s visit to Iowa suggested that he would be a long shot, but noted that it was not unprecedented for a losing candidate for the US Senate to win the race for president. Abraham Lincoln did it it in 1860.

However, I would feel comfortable saying to Brown, “You, sir, are no Abraham Lincoln.”

Susan Davis