Making health care affordable

July 16, 2012 | Lynn Nicholas

Reducing payments to hospitals doesn’t reduce health care costs, it just shifts them to someone else

In seeking to trim health care costs, the state must not try to exert too much control over providers, writes Lynn Nicholas, the president and CEO of the Massachusetts Hospital Association. In fact, overzealous expansion of centralized government control could impede rapid innovation and improved efficiency, rather than facilitate those goals.


State health care bill should focus on areas of broad agreement

The long effort to develop an effective cost-containment law for the Massachusetts health-care system has entered a worrisome phase. With just two weeks left in the Legislature’s formal session, a conference committee is reportedly making little headway on resolving critical differences and arriving at compromise legislation. The committee must put aside egos and pride of authorship and focus on crafting realistic, light-touch legislation that promotes cost containment goals without over-reaching.

June 22, 2012 | Daniel Vasella

The lesson from abroad: spending more doesn’t always lead to better care

A recent comparison of world health shows that countries that spend less often have higher quality care, writes Daniel Vasella, chairman of Novartis. No one country has the secret recipe: diabetes treatment is better in the UK, for instance, while the US has better breast cancer results. The study shows that countries still have a lot to learn from one other before they try to legislate sweeping health care changes.

June 19, 2012 | Ropper, Amato, and Samuels

// Put away the red tape

As it seeks to trim health costs, the government must avoid burdening doctors with even more paperwork requirements, write physicians Allan H. Ropper, Anthony A. Amato, and Martin A. Samuels.

June 14, 2012 | Dr. Angelo Volandes

More help navigating end-of-life options can improve care for dying patients — and reduce costs

Dying patients often receive aggressive, expensive treatment that many would reject if they had a fuller understanding of their options, writes Dr. Angelo Volandes. A series of videos showing what end-of-life care really looks like has allowed patients at a handful of hospitals to make better informed choices. An intervention that first and foremost leads to better patient-centered health care — and also happens to lower costs — is a good thing, and more hospitals should embrace it.

June 1, 2012 | David U. Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler

Single-payer health care would save billions for Massachusetts

A public health insurance system like Canada’s would dramatically slice health bills in Massachusetts by cutting out the insurance-company middleman, write doctors David U. Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler. A single-payer plan would also enable the state to drive a harder bargain with pharmaceutical companies for cheaper drugs. To make care more affordable, the state should also change the way doctors and hospitals are paid, so that money goes to services the state needs the most.

July 18, 2012 | Eric Beyer

State needs to take stock before expanding health payment methods employers are rejecting

A few health insurance plans already feature innovative new strategies to lower costs, writes Eric Beyer, the CEO and president of Tufts Medical Center — but few employers are buying them. Before the state embraces calls to make those types of plans more widespread, we need to understand why employers don’t like them.

Robert brown

Massachusetts’ health care cost containment option could affect life sciences economy

Lawmakers should be aware of possible unintended consequences as they consider health care legislation and its effect on our state’s ability to compete in the international life sciences economy.

June 22, 2012 | Alan Sager and Deborah Socolar

Beacon Hill’s health plans are doomed to failure

Massachusetts should look overseas for successful strategies to make health spending sustainable, write Alan Sager and Deborah Socolar. The plans under considersation in the Legislature are too weak to be effective.

June 21, 2012 | Philip W. Johnston

// 20 years later, Weld’s deregulation of hospital rates looms large as the root of today’s cost crisis

The state’s decision to stop regulating hospital prices in 1992 was a mistake that unleashed the cost increases of today, writes Philip W. Johnston, a health care consultant and former state official.

June 20, 2012 | Donald M. Berwick

// In Elinor Ostrom’s legacy, a lesson for Beacon Hill

The work of the Nobel Prize-winning economist, who died last week, should inspire the state as it looks for ways to rein in health care costs, writes former Medicare chief Donald M. Berwick.

June 15, 2012 | Shannon Brownlee

Mass. has too many hospitals for its own good

Unless Massachusetts finds a way to limit growth in the number of both hospitals and specialists, the state’s efforts to control health care spending are likely to fail, says Shannon Brownlee. How can more hospital beds and more doctors lead to worse care and higher spending? Basic economics would suggest that more hospitals competing with one another would lead to lower costs — but that’s not the case in health care.

June 1, 2012 | Jon B. Hurst

State lawmakers must put our bloated health care system on a diet

To bring down the price of health insurance, lawmakers should relax some of the mandated coverage items that add to premiums, writes Jon B. Hurst of the Retailers Association of Massachusetts. Lawmakers should also put pressure on the state’s bloated hospitals to slim down, and reward individual consumers who stay healthy. And they must act urgently: costs that have skyrocketed an average of 14 percent per year over the last five years are crippling small businesses.

Join the conversation

How should Massachusetts cut health care costs? Send your ideas to We will highlight the best on


Health law primer

// The Mass. health care law

The law’s history and effect on Massachusetts and beyond.