Angry words after ambulance is diverted from trauma center
Richard McGrath was already struggling with health problems. The 82-year-old suffers from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, his daughter said, and then on Thursday, his car apparently skidded across ice in Easton and crashed into two trees, leaving him with a fractured neck and spine and some broken ribs.
He needed trauma care at Boston Medical Center, but protesters had shut down northbound Interstate 93 at East Milton Square, and the ambulance carrying McGrath had to turn back and head to Good Samaritan Medical Center in Brockton — a hospital without a trauma center.
“I’m so angry right now,” said McGrath’s daughter, Nadine McGrath. “I understand trying to make a point. But why that? Why would you do that? Why? I just don’t understand what the purpose for that is. Ambulance, fire, police — you’re not just inconveniencing commuters trying to get to work. . . . He could have died.”
The two groups of protesters involved in highway shutdowns said they were trying to call attention to what they say is racial oppression, by police and others. The effort began about 7:30 a.m.
Easton Fire Chief Kevin Partridge said firefighters driving the ambulance with McGrath on board were en route to Boston Medical at 8:03 a.m. when they were alerted to the bottleneck created by protesters who closed off the Southeast Expressway.
“He had some significant injuries, and the paramedics determined it would have been in his best interest to get directly to a Level 1 trauma center,” Partridge said. “They were transporting him to Boston Medical Center when they diverted. That’s where he should have gone.”
State Police Colonel Timothy Alben pointed to the Easton ambulance diversion as an example of the “unintended consequences” of the highway protest. Alben criticized demonstrators as being “immature” and “irresponsible.”
Partridge told State Police that officials decided to divert the ambulance “for fear of the patient expiring if they could not reach Boston Medical Center due to the traffic gridlock created by the parties blocking Rt. 93,” according to a police report.
McGrath was transferred from Brockton to Massachusetts General Hospital later Thursday, his daughter said, because he needed a trauma center. He was listed in fair condition Thursday night.
Partridge said the single-car crash occurred at 7:23 a.m., and firefighters were on the scene four minutes later. The vehicle was wedged between two trees, and McGrath, a father of seven and grandfather of 15, was trapped inside the mangled wreckage, Partridge said.
Firefighters first had to cut down a tree and then extricate McGrath from the vehicle, the chief said. That took about 20 minutes, and McGrath was on board a department ambulance at 8:02 a.m.
The diversion occurred about a minute later.
The authorities did not identify McGrath, but his family members provided his name, and said he lives in West Bridgewater. Nadine McGrath said she wanted her father’s story to get out “because I don’t want [protesters] to ever do that again.”
Her father is a laid-back jokester who has been married to her mother for about 55 years, she said.
“He would give you the shirt off his back,” she said.
On Thursday before the crash, she said, her father was dropping her brother off at work.
A relative sent her pictures of her father in the hospital, she said, and his eyes were puffy and black and blue, and his forehead was gashed.
“He’s kind of frail as it is, that’s why we’re worried,” Nadine McGrath said.
McGrath’s granddaughter, Carson McGrath, 19, said she was not angry at the protesters, but that disrupting people’s daily lives can be problematic.
“I think the protests are good, but I think at the same time, people like my grandpa who are trying to get to the hospital and couldn’t, that’s a big problem,” she said.
The Easton fire chief said he felt protesters made the wrong choice.
“They have a right to protest, but they can do it without affecting public safety,’’ he said. “When you affect public safety in any way, what you are doing is wrong.’’
A representative of the protesters listed on a statement issued by demonstrators did not return phone or e-mail requests for comment.
Nadine McGrath said her family was thankful that her father was still alive, but said she could not understand how a protest about the value of life could put her father at risk.
“You’re angry because of police brutality and lives lost, but you’re willing to kill other people to get your point across?” she said, her voice breaking. “I understand your plight. But to put public safety in jeopardy is just moronic.”
On Thursday night, she said that her father is expected to transfer to a regular room within four to five days, and then probably will move to a rehabilitation facility.
“He’s stable and he’s alert, but he’s pretty badly banged up,” she said. “He’s got broken ribs, a spinal cord injury, some swelling in his head and brain tissue and his eye is really banged up . . . but he’s alert and his toes are moving.”
The family explained to Richard McGrath that his ambulance was delayed, but he has not formed an opinion.
“He’s kind of out of it,” Nadine McGrath said. “It’s going to be a long road. More tests need to be done, but we’re just hoping that at some point he’ll be able to walk.”