fb-pixelMass. has a troubled record on prison suicides - The Boston Globe Skip to main content

Mass. has a troubled record on prison suicides

The former Patriots tight end, serving a life sentence for murder, committed suicide in prison Wedneday morning, the Department of Correction said.
The former Patriots tight end, serving a life sentence for murder, committed suicide in prison Wedneday morning, the Department of Correction said.

Massachusetts prisons for years have had a troubled track record when it comes to suicides by inmates.

The latest data from the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics show that there were 32 suicides per 100,000 state and federal prisoners in Massachusetts between 2001 and 2014 — the fourth-highest such rate in the country and about twice the national average.

In what appears to be the most recent case of inmate suicide, former New England Patriots star Aaron Hernandez was found dead, hanging in his cell at the Souza-Baranowski Correctional Center in Shirley, early Wednesday morning.

Between 2005 and 2006, a dozen inmate suicides were reported at Massachusetts prisons — including two at the Souza-Baranowski Correctional Center — prompting intense scrutiny of the state Department of Correction. Most of the suicides were committed in segregation units by inmates with histories of mental illness and attempted suicides.


Advocacy groups sued the department in 2007 alleging civil rights violations, just as a Globe Spotlight series revealed deepening mental illness and misery behind the walls of the state’s prisons.

That series also identified numerous problems, including botched background screenings on suicidal inmates, missing mental health records, and skipped security rounds by officers.

The correction department hired a consultant, made several improvements to the segregation unit system, and attempted to reach a deal on the lawsuit.

However, those negotiations failed, and plans for change were shelved because of the state’s fiscal crisis.

The department then saw another sharp increase in suicides, with 13 prisoners killing themselves between 2009 and 2010, including three at the Souza-Baranowski Correctional Center.

In response to an outcry from inmate advocates, the state rehired the consultant who had conducted the 2007 review.

The consultant said his subsequent review of the prisons, released in 2011, found that the Correction Department had once again made reforms, including increased training and new protocols for assessing inmates’ mental illnesses.


The department also created new alternatives to the segregation unit. In 2012, as part of a settlement of the advocates’ lawsuit, a federal judge ordered the department to maintain those alternatives.

But suicides have continued in recent years at state prisons, including six in 2014; one of those cases was at the Souza-Baranowski Correctional Center and was the most recent inmate suicide at that facility until Hernandez’ this week.

And in recent months, prisoner advocacy groups have said the state is unlawfully placing prisoners with serious mental illness in solitary confinement despite that settlement.

And a recent Globe Spotlight series on the state’s failed mental health care system highlighted the often-inadequate care provided in prisons, where at least 30 percent of inmates suffer from mental illness.

The Spotlight Team reported on one case in which an inmate diagnosed with a serious mental illness was sent to segregation at MCI-Cedar Junction at Walpole with tragic consequences: Joseph Vyce, a 35-year-old with bipolar disorder, hanged himself in 2014 after months in the isolation ward known as the Department Disciplinary Unit, where inmates are locked in 23 hours a day.

Nationwide, and in Massachusetts, illness — including cancer and heart, liver, and lung diseases — is by far the most common cause of death for state and federal prisoners, federal statistics show.

Suicide is the next most common cause, followed by homicides and drug and alcohol poisoning.


If you or someone you know is having thoughts of suicide, call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-8255.

Prison suicide rate, by state, 2001-2014 Figures reflect both state and federal prisoners in each state. (One asterisk (*) denotes that that in that state, prisons and jails form one integrated system and the rates are based on total jail and prison populations. Two asterisks (**) denotes that the figure should be interpreted with caution because there were too few cases to provide a reliable rate.)
State Suicide rate per 100,000 inmates, 2001-2014
Rhode Island* 45
Utah 44
Montana 34
Massachusetts 32
Alaska* 31
New Hampshire** 30
Hawaii* 29
Idaho 28
South Dakota 28
Delaware* 26
Vermont* & ** 26
Connecticut* 24
New Mexico 23
Nebraska 21
New York 21
California 20
Iowa 20
Maryland 20
Oklahoma 19
Wisconsin 19
Colorado 18
Minnesota 18
Wyoming** 18
Arizona 17
Arkansas 17
Nevada 17
Illinois 16
Indiana 16
Michigan 16
Oregon 16
Pennsylvania 16
Texas 16
Tennessee 15
Kansas 14
Mississippi 13
New Jersey 13
Ohio 13
South Carolina 13
Washington 13
Missouri 12
Maine** 11
Georgia 10
Virginia 10
Kentucky 9
Louisiana 9
Florida 8
West Virginia** 8
North Carolina 7
Alabama 6
North Dakota** 5
SOURCE: Bureau of Justice Statistics

Maria Cramer and Jenna Russell conrtibuted to this report. Matt Rocheleau can be reached at matthew.rocheleau@globe.com. Follow him on Twitter @mrochele