fb-pixel Skip to main content
OPINION

Afghanistan war vets are enraged and hurting – reach out and listen to them

While most troops are justifiably proud of what they did at the tactical, local level, they’re now seeing their efforts go up in smoke. I fear that the mental health of some of them will unravel so unrelentingly they’ll take their own lives.

US Army veteran Daryn LaVoie, who is blind, shares a moment with horse Riley during a program pairing horses with veterans, on July 11 in Indio, Calif. LaVoie, a combat veteran, served during Operation Desert Storm from 1993 to1997 and suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder after his return home. He attempted to commit suicide in 2017 with his gun; the bullet severed both his optic nerves rendering him blind.
US Army veteran Daryn LaVoie, who is blind, shares a moment with horse Riley during a program pairing horses with veterans, on July 11 in Indio, Calif. LaVoie, a combat veteran, served during Operation Desert Storm from 1993 to1997 and suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder after his return home. He attempted to commit suicide in 2017 with his gun; the bullet severed both his optic nerves rendering him blind.Mario Tama/Getty

As a US major general stepped aboard a C-17 cargo plane in Kabul this month and became the last American soldier to leave Afghanistan, my inbox was filling up with messages of despair from Afghan war veterans. They were witnessing a disastrous end to the war for which they put their lives on the line, and are now feeling bereft, demoralized, and desperate.

Here’s a sample of what they wrote:

“I feel hurt, anger, resentment, anguish, rage, disbelief, powerlessness. My heart hurts.”

“I’m devastated, heartbroken, and so sad. Haven’t left my apartment for a week.”

“I’m in a very dark place.”

Advertisement



These are the voices of some of our very best Americans, who fought to defeat our enemies and build a better Afghanistan. They lost friends in battle and saw their buddies maimed. While most troops are justifiably proud of what they did at the tactical, local level, they’re now seeing their efforts go up in smoke. They’re angry, sad, hurting, and confused, and I fear that the mental health of some of them will unravel so unrelentingly they’ll take their own lives. The risk of suicide is rising among veterans. A Rand Corporation report finds that between 2005 and 2019, the last year studied, the suicide rate has risen faster among veterans than it has for nonveteran adults. It now stands at about 2.5 times the rate of the civilian population.

These Afghan war veterans are revealing themselves to me because they know I can identify.

In 2003, I helped lead US forces into Iraq. The rage and disgust I felt toward senior policy officials in the early days of the Iraq War are echoed in what Afghan vets are telling me today.

In Iraq, my comrades and I were sickened that misguided policies helped fuel the insurgency that crippled our war aims and led to the injury or death of thousands of our troops. I saw the consequences of tragic policy decisions up close on the battlefield.

Advertisement



In my case, those stressors combined with a genetic predisposition for bipolar disorder that expressed itself on and off the battlefield. By 2014, as I served as the president of the National Defense University, my bipolar disorder became acute, ended my career, and pushed me into a battle for my life. I was tortured by vivid images of my own violent death, what psychiatrists call “passive suicidal ideations.” What started years earlier in Iraq has never left me.

Melissa Gauntner, a retired Army first sergeant who has dealt with dual traumas and at times has been gripped with panic, in El Paso, Aug. 16.
Melissa Gauntner, a retired Army first sergeant who has dealt with dual traumas and at times has been gripped with panic, in El Paso, Aug. 16.Joel Angel Juarez/NYT

How many Afghan vets are struggling with a mental health crisis of their own — or soon will? I count myself lucky to be alive. I had a commander who ordered me to get a psychiatric evaluation, a wife and family who stuck with me, and a friend who helped get me into a Veterans Administration hospital, which provided excellent care.

Among the biggest factors in mental health disorders are depression, post-traumatic stress, traumatic brain injury, survivors’ guilt, and bipolar disorder. And when combined with trauma in relationships, legal issues, and financial problems, the risk goes up.

Bottom line: Reach out and contact a veteran. Help them the way I was helped. Ask how they’re doing. Let them vent or cry, or both. And listen. If they display despair, signs of mental illness, or suicidal thoughts, encourage them to get medical help immediately, and help them do so. Then follow up.

Advertisement



And for Afghan vets, check on yourself and your buddies, listen, and observe. Realize that it’s OK to not be OK. Recognizing and admitting a problem is a sign of strength, not weakness. And if you or your buddy is not doing well, go get medical help — immediately, as you would for a heart attack. Given the insidious interrelationship between mental health and suicide, it could very well be a matter of life and death, this time off the battlefield.

Gregg Martin is a combat veteran, bipolar survivor, and retired two-star Army general. He is a former president of the National Defense University and a graduate of West Point and MIT.